Preferred Citation: Hill, Marilynn Wood. Their Sisters' Keepers: Prostitution in New York City, 1830-1870. Berkeley:  University of California Press,  1993. http://ark.cdlib.org/ark:/13030/ft8199p209/


 

INDEX

Page references to illustrations print in italic .

A

Abortion, 23 , 59 , 141 , 235 -41;

laws against, and their enforcement, 237 , 241 , 388 n.66

Abuse, by parent or spouse, 76 , 270 , 321 -22, 325

Acton, William, 23 , 61 , 349 n.42

Adams, Maria (or Marie), 105 , 185 , 223 , 302 , 309 -10

Adultery, and laws against, 140 -41, 151 , 165 , 371 n. 103

Advocate of Moral Reform , 20 , 154

African Americans. See Black New York residents; Prostitutes: black; Prostitution: black and interracial; Racism

Age of consent, 52

Alcoholism, 76 -77. See also Prostitutes: and alcohol and drugs

Aldermen, and Board of, 135 -36, 154 -55, 157 ;

Police Department Reorganization Committee Report (1844), 30 , 124 , 136

Almshouse, 18 , 23 , 117 , 234 , 389 n.78

American Tract Society, 17

Andrews, Carolyn, 185

Andrews, Emma, 185 , 309

Anthony, Mary, 43 -44, 99 , 311

Anthony, Susan B., 138

Anti-feminism, 167

Anti-prostitution laws, 173 . See also Disorderly house/persons: law; Vagrancy law

Applegate, William, 292

Archer, Lawrence, 180

Arkley, Mary, 238 -39

Armstrong, Captain, 45

Arrest records, 53 , 119 , 127 , 351 n.63, 367 n. 20. See also Disorderly house/persons: arrests; Vagrancy law: arrests

Aspinwall, William H., 178

Assignation houses, 196 , 198 , 225 , 381 nn.60, 63, 382 n.65;

number of, 31 , 381 n.58;

mentioned, 42 , 44 , 45 , 50 , 137 , 165 , 193 , 230 , 275 , 313 -14

Association for the Improvement of the Condition of the Poor (AICP), 85 -86, 213

Astor House Hotel, 141 , 231

Austin, Kate, 58

B

Badger, Susan Matilda, 75 , 313

Bagioli, Antonio, 281 , 394 n.90

Bagioli, Teresa (Mrs. Dan Sickles), 281 , 394 n.90

Baker, Elizabeth, 167

Baker, Mrs., 271 -72

Balch, Mrs., 241

Ballard, Francis, 141

Ballard, Henry, 141 -42, 170

Baltimore, 272 , 274

Barnes, Mary Ann, 273

Barney, Ebenezer, 57


422

Barrett, Eleanor, 179 , 314

Barton, Frances, 302

Barton, Mary, 294 , 296

Battery, the, 187 , 209 -10, 266

Bawdy houses, 126 . See also Brothels

Beach, Moses Y. (editor of the Sun), 161

Beckett, James, 290

Bed houses, 199

Beekman, Henry, 35

Belle View, 316

Bellmire, Ellen, 170

Bellows, Rev. Dr. Henry W., 30

Belmont, Cary, 302

Bennett, James G. (editor of the Herald ), 161 -62, 374 n.38

Bennett, Mrs., 56

Betdell, James, 160

Berger, Patience, 43 , 44 -45, 64 , 154 , 311 , 313 ;

assets of, 44 , 99 -100, 105

Berry, Frank (Francis), 36 -37, 155 , 271 , 291 , 297 , 298 , 300

Berry, Mary (Mrs. Frank Berry, née Mary Cisco), 36 -37, 40 , 105 , 151 , 155 , 200 , 269 , 271 , 291 , 311 , 334 -35;

as madam of Jewett, 12 , 262 , 275 , 279 , 298 -301, 302

Birth control. See Contraception

Bishop, Mary, 248

Blackmail and extortion, 131 , 149 , 230 . See also Panel houses

Black Maria, 111

Black New York residents, 55 , 176 -77, 191 -92, 352 n.71

Blackwell, Elizabeth, 110

Blackwell's Island Hospital, 23 , 233

Blackwell's Island penitentiary and workhouse, 46 , 111 , 157

Blankman, Edmon, 103 , 282 , 284

Blaylock, Mary, 185

Blisset, Hannah, 200 , 297 -98, 300 -302

Bloodgood, Justice, 211

Boardinghouses, respectable, 93 , 180 , 197 ;

keepers of, 361 n.82, 382 n.65

Bonner, Mary, 315

Bowen, Eliza. See Jumel, Eliza

Bowen, Mary, 315

Bowery, the, 192 -93, 209 -10

Bowery Theatre, 199 , 200 , 202 , 205 , 271 , 294 , 301

Bowne, Walter, 178

Bowyer, Officer, 231

Box, Mary Jane, 42 , 76

Boyd, Ann, 185

Boyd, John, 167

Boyd, Mr. (Jewett's client), 13

Boyd's New York City Tax Book , 39

Brace, Charles Loring, 342 n.33

Brackett, Kitty, 157

Brakey, Eliza, 45 -46

Brandley, Harriet, 185

Brewer, Mary Ann, 301

Brewster, Honey, 239 , 249 -50

Bridewell (prison), 271

Briggs, Charlotte, 365 n.98

Briggs, John, 169

Brink, Dennis, 150 -51

Broadway, 209 -12;

hotels and theaters on, 198 -200;

mentioned, 31 , 95 , 109 -10, 112 , 115 , 145 , 171 , 177 , 178 , 186 , 193 -95, 207 , 282 , 301

Broadway Theatre, 200 , 382 n.68

Brothel addresses/prostitution locations Anthony Street (later Worth Street), 104 , 166 , 183 , 185 , 191 , 271 ; 28

Anthony, 35 , 183 , 185 , 191 , 295 ;

Bleeker Street, 210 , 307 ;

Bowery East area, 97 , 186 , 192 -93, 209 ;

Broadway West area, 97 , 186 , 193 -94;

Broome Street, 99 , 155 , 239 ;

Canal Street, 31 , 183 , 207 , 210 ;

Centre Street, 129 , 312 ;

Chapel Street (later West Broadway), 12 , 99 , 100 -101, 202 , 205 ;

Cherry Street, 187 -88;

Church Street, 39 , 43 , 44 , 55 , 64 , 99 , 104 , 131 , 133 , 153 , 157 , 167 , 169 , 183 , 185 , 241 , 315 , 316 , 363 n.90, 381 n.54;

Cotlears Hook (The Hook), 27 , 41 , 78 , 187 , 188 , 215 ;

Crosby Street, 183 , 315 ;

Cross Street, 104 , 183 , 191 , 221 ;

Desbrosses Street, 183 ;

Dock areas, 97 , 186 , 187 -88;

Duane Street, 12 , 36 , 39 , 99 , 101 , 110 , 155 , 157 , 169 , 183 , 220 , 271 , 284 ;

136 Duane, 102 , 104 , 185 , 228 ;

Elizabeth Street, 46 , 134 , 295 ;

Elm Street, 38 , 153 , 183 , 275 ;

Five Points, 18 , 49 , 95 -96, 97 , 119 , 186 , 188 -92, 206 -7, 215 , 254 , 287 -88, 295 , 307 , 380 nn.37, 40;

Fortieth, 186 , 195 ;

Fourteenth Street, 195 , 210 ;

Franklin House, 45 ;

Franklin Street, 71 , 74 , 88 ;

3 Franklin, 12 , 296 , 315 ;

Grand Street, 210 , 249 , 253 , 310 ;


423

Greene Street, 99 , 104 , 182 , 194 , 229 , 301 ;

Greenwich Street, 122 ;

Hotel de Wood, 220 ;

Houston Street, 182 -83, 208 ;

Laurence House, 12 ;

Laurens Street, 286 ;

Leonard Street, 99 , 102 , 104 , 151 , 159 , 161 , 171 , 183 , 185 , 212 , 215 , 232 , 280 , 315 ;

55 Leonard, 104 , 182 , 183 , 185 , 290 , 302 ;

Little Water Street, 191 ;

Mercer Street, 54 , 56 , 99 , 102 , 104 , 179 , 183 , 194 , 212 , 215 , 253 , 282 , 291 , 292 , 302 ;

Mott Street, 38 , 73 , 100 -101, 183 ;

Mulberry Street, 231 ;

Murray Street, 182 ;

Orange Street, 38 , 145 , 168 , 183 , 191 , 226 ;

Paradise Square, 190 ;

Prince Street, 35 , 210 ;

Reade Street (Reed), 38 , 130 , 168 , 183 ;

Rialto, 195 ;

Seven Sisters, 195 ;

Seventh Avenue, 168 , 195 ;

Staple Street, 183 ;

Tenderloin district, 192 , 195 ;

Thomas Street, 99 , 129 , 185 ;

41 Thomas, 12 , 34 -35, 64 , 129 , 220 , 322 , 325 ;

Thompson Street, 310 ;

Twelfth Street, 178 , 180 , 195 , 282 ;

Twenty-Fifth Street, 195 ;

Twenty-Fourth Street, 183 ;

Twenty-Second Street, 195 ;

Twenty-Seventh Street, 195 ;

Union Square, 195 ;

Walnut Street, 70 , 273 ;

Warren Street, 183 ;

Washington Square North area, 97 , 186 , 194 -95;

Water Street, 87 , 187 -88, 207 , 211 , 215 , 228 ;

West Broadway, 99 , 183 ;

White Street, 130 , 305 ;

Wooster Street, 99 , 194 . See also Battery; Bowery; Broadway; Five Points

"Brothel bullies," defined, 376 n. 58. See also "Bullies"

Brothelkeepers (madams, managers), 40 , 91 -94, 183 , 185 , 196 -97, 222 -26, 269 , 290 -92, 361 n.82, 365 n.98;

ages of, 48 , 50 ;

business and personal skills of, 223 -25;

as exploiters of prostitutes, 94 , 299 -300;

gender, race, and ethnicity of, 55 -58, 94 , 290 -92, 352 n.69, 361 n.83;

as "mothers" and friends, 224 , 299 ;

and personality of house, 222 -23;

profits of, 99 -103, 105 ;

and violence against prostitutes, 295 -96. See also names of individual brothelkeepers and madams

Brothels/prostitution boardinghouses: children in, 57 , 223 -24, 313 -15;

Creole, 55 -56;

directories and guidebooks, 25 , 31 , 55 , 56 , 179 , 194 , 214 -15, 253 , 302 ;

distribution patterns of, 31 , 96 , 97 , 178 -81, 183 , 185 , 186 -95, 362 n.88, 363 n.89;

fees to customer, 88 , 198 , 226 , 227 , 244 , 360 nn.70-71;

German, 221 , 291 ;

as home and family, 224 , 299 -300;

landlords of, 29 , 133 , 181 , 292 ;

long-term addresses of, 184 -85;

lower-class, 178 , 190 , 193 -94, 215 , 221 , 232 ;

and neighbors and community, 127 -30, 177 -81, 216 , 227 -28,

number of, 29 , 31 , 33 , 343 nn. 39-40, 345 n.49, 381 n.58;

as primary institution, 196 -99;

rents in, 88 -89;

rituals and practices of, 36 -37, 225 -27;

security of, 222 , 225 -26;

servants in, 57 -58, 89 , 223 -24;

and social role for men, 251 , 253 -54, 261 -62, 299 ;

theft in, 165 -66, 228 -29;

upper-class, 193 , 195 , 220 -21, 232 ;

as workplace, 195 -97, 219 -22 See also Assignation houses; Panel houses; Police/law enforcers; Prostitutes' relationships with men: as clients; Prostitutes' relationships with men: and violence

Brown, Charlotte, 309 -10

Brown, Jane, 228

Brown, Julia, 105 , 130 , 165 , 173 , 178 , 180 , 181 , 185 , 194 , 224 , 365 n.98, 386 n. 22, 396 n. 117

Brown, Lydia. See Norman, Amelia

Brown, Margaret, 105 , 180 , 302

Brown, Mrs., 155

Brown, Rachel, 314

Brown, Susan, 78

Browning, Mary and Jacob, 290

Buchanan, James, 102 , 268 , 281

Buchanan, Sarah, 74 , 313 , 357 n. 29

"Bullies," 167 -68, 269 , 271 , 362 n.84, 376 n. 58

Buntline, Ned (E. Z. C. Judson): Mysteries and Miseries of New York , 218 ;

Ned Buntline's Own , 161 . See also Judson, Edward Zane Carroll

Burgen, Elizabeth, 233

Burk, Ann, 270

Burke, Mary, 70


424

Burke, Mr. (Jewett's client), 13

Burke, Mr. (Mrs. Baker's client), 271 -72

Burr (Vidal), 11

Burr, Aaron, 282 -84

Bush, Margaret Ann, 311

Bushnell, Mrs., 185

Butler, Ann and Catherine, 310 , 311

Butler, Anne M., 349 n.44

C

Cabarets, 209

Cannon, Kate, 180

Carey, Matthew (Plea for the Poor ), 82 , 84 -85

Carlock, Jacob, 151

Carter, Enoch, 167

Censuses of 1850 and 1855, 31 -32, 56 , 59 , 61 , 192 , 301 -2, 308 -10, 313 -315, 345 n.49, 363 n.90

C[handler], Charles (Jewett's client), 261 , 265 , 333 , 335

Chapman, George, 129

Chapman, William, 204 , 383 n.85

Charities, 85 -86

Charles, Harriet, 124

Charles, James (ahas Green Jacket), 231

Chatham Theatre, 79 , 200

Chichester, John (Chichester gang), 167 -68

Children: abandonment of, see Infants, abandonment of; illegitimate, 59 , 312 ;

molestation and sexual abuse of, 51 , 351 n.58;

mortality rates, 59 , 312 , 354 n.90;

prostitution of, see Prostitutes, child

Children's Aid Society, 213

Cholera epidemic (1833), 45

Cisco, Mary. See Berry, Mary

Clark, Eliza, 39

Clark, Mary Louisa, 305 , 306

Clarke, Susan, 240

Class, role of, 2

Clients of prostitutes. See Prostitutes' relationships with men: as clients

Clifton, Emma, 180 , 302

Clinton, Mary, 302

Cochran, Catherine, 38 , 167 , 211

Coin, Adeliza, 295

Collect Pond, 190

Columbia College, 194 , 217

Committee of Fifteen, 340 n. 17

Common Council, 27 , 86 , 125 , 146 , 148 , 154 , 242

Concert saloons, 206 -7

Conch, 272 -73

Connelly, Justice Michael, 126 , 368 n.43

Consent, age of, 52

Contraception, 235 , 236 , 242

Cook, Caroline (C.C.), 179 , 223

Cook, Mr. (Jewett's client), 261 -63

Cooper, Rebecca, 185

Cooper, Sarah Ann, 295

Corlis, Charles, murder of, 165

Cornell, Mrs., 253 , 311 , 399 n.54

Corruption of law officials, 147 -50, 157 , 372 n. 10

Cory, E. T., 239

Cosine, Catharine, 289

Costello, Madame, 237

Cost of living, 84 -85

Courts:

of General Sessions, 116 , 126 , 127 , 151 , 160 ;

Mayor's Office as, 109 , 366 n.3;

of Special Sessions, 160 , 162 ;

Superior and Supreme, 123 , 134 , 160 , 182

Coyle, Mary Ann (Cole), 143

COYOTE (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics), 400 n. 5

Crapsey, Edward, 219

Criminal underground, 21

Cross-dressing, 307 -8

"Cult of domesticity," 17

"Cult of true womanhood," 17 , 67

Cunningham, Mrs., 12

D

Dairey, Elizabeth, 155

Dale, Clara, 165

Daley, Judge C. P., 132 , 173

Dance houses/halls, 188 , 207 -8

"Dangerous classes," 385 n.4

Darragh, Elizabeth, 314

Darwin, Charles, 242

Davis, Gertie, 214

Davis, Rebecca, 130 -31

Davis, William, 239 -41, 249

Day, Frances, 74

Dean, Caroline, 396 n. 114

Death rates. See Children: mortality rates; Prostitutes: mortality and suicide of

Decker, Julia, 78 , 288 , 310

Decker, Miss (Mrs. Hamilton Dobbs), 288

Delaplaine, John F., 133 , 292 , 369 n.70


425

Demarest, Mary Ann, 305 -6

Demographic patterns, New York City, 176 -77

Denny, Sarah, 79

Devins, John, 134

Diamond, Dennis, 270

Diaries, 182 . See also Dunlap, William; Hone, Philip; Strong, George T.; Taylor, Robert

Dickens, Charles, 191 , 380 n.40

Disease. See Venereal disease

Disorderly house/persons:

arrests, 39 , 127 -28, 133 , 271 , 305 -6;

law, disorderly house, 126 -27, 131 -34, 151 -52, 155 ;

law, disorderly persons, 113 -14, 116 -17, 126 -33, 149

Divorce, 286 , 290 ;

testimony for, 151 , 159 , 165 , 182

Domestic servants, 48 , 59 , 82 , 83 -84, 340 n. 16, 352 n.64

Dory, Phoebe, 167 , 169 , 183

Double standard, 60 , 66 , 74 -75, 112 , 139 -40

Dowell, William, 160

Doyen (Dorrance), Dorcas. See Jewett, Helen

Drake, Mary, 295 -96

Dressmakers. See Seamstresses

Drinking (dram) establishments, 127 , 188 , 206

Drug addiction, 318

Dunlap, William, 182 , 282

E

East River, 187

Easy, Bill (George P. Marston), 261 -64, 335

Economic conditions, of nineteenth-century women, 81 -86. See also Prostitution: economic or occupational opportunity of

Edmonds, Judge J. W., 157

Edmonds, Matilda, 166

Edmonds, Sarah (Mrs. George), 305 -6

Edward (Jewett's client), 15 , 264 -65

Ellington, George, 219 , 230 , 244 -46, 270

Emily (Jewett's friend), 304 -5, 335

Employers, sexual exploitation by, 73 -74, 86 , 313

Englis, Jenny, 102 , 104

"English Ann," 198

"English Nance," 156

Erben, Alderman, 155

Erriott, Catherine, 305

Ethnic neighborhoods, New York City, 119 , 176 -77

Evangelical reform movement, 18 , 21

F

Family, nineteenth-century, 16 -17, 213

Farmer, Ann, 271 , 298 -99, 318 , 335

Farryall, Joseph, 49 -50, 71 -72, 74 , 291 , 356 n. 22

Fast Man's Directory and Lovers' Guide (H. D. Eastman), 55

Faulkner, Eliza and Catherine, 310

Felt, D., 264

Female Magdalen Society Home, 43

Feminists, 138

Fifth Avenue, 177 , 195 , 207

Fish, Hamilton (governor), 157

Fisher, Eliza, 57 , 165 -66, 231 -32, 317

Fisher, Sarah, 365 n.98

Five Points, 95 -96, 188 -92, 189 , 215 , 243 , 380 nn. 37, 40. See also Brothel addresses/prostitution locations: Five Points

Five Points House of Industry, 192

Ford, William, 170 -71

Foreign-born residents, 53 -54, 351 n. 63, 352 n.64. See also Immigrants/immigration

Forrest, Edwin and Catherine, 151 , 165 , 225

Foster, George G. (New York in Slices ;

New York by Gaslight ;

New York Naked ), 202 , 217 -18, 230

Foster, Mary Ann, 185 , 295

Fowler, Mary (Mrs. Joseph Fowler), 131 -33, 152 , 173 , 295

Fox, Margaret, 315

Frampton, Maria, 316

Frances, Jane, 56

Franklin Theatre, 205

Frisby, Emeline, 155

Fuller, Hannah, 170 -71

Furman, Adelia. See Miller, Adeline

Furman, Mary Ann, 165

G

Gage, Dr. Thomas E., 239 -41, 249

Gale, George, 167

Gallagher, Ellen, 239 -41, 388 n.73

Gallagher, Mary, 100 , 102 , 105 , 299

Gamble, Mary, 169


426

Gambling, 188

Gardner, M., 223

Gender, role of and biases, 2 , 112 -13, 139

The Gentleman's Directory: The Gentleman's Companion, New York City in 1870 , 214 , 215

German immigrants, 54 , 84 , 180 , 352 n.64. See also Brothels/prostitution boardinghouses: German; Prostitutes: foreign-born

Gilfoyle, Timothy J., 255

Goldman, Marion, 308

Goldstreng, Antoinette, 165

Goodrich, Augustus, 152

Goodrich, Lizzie, 232

Goodwin, Clara, 309

Gordon, Clara, 102 -4

Graham, Jenny. See Western, Jane Graham

Graham, Mary E., 280 -81

Grand juries related to prostitution, 30 , 125 , 162

Green, Matilda, 185

Green, Mr., 44

Grey, Jenny, 180

Grey Nunnery, 70

Griscom, John, 137

Groggeries. See Drinking establishments; Saloons

Groneman-Pernicorn, Carol, 192

Grovenor, Mary Ann, 170

H

Habeas corpus, writs of, 111 , 120 -21

Hadden, Angela, 73 -74

Hall, Eliza, 306

Hall, Sarah, 295

Halliday, Samuel B., 192

Hamet, Charles, 124 , 126

Hamilton, Ellen, 102

Hannington's Diorama, 85

Harassment. See Prostitutes: harassment of

"Harpies," 262 , 391 n.26

Harrington, Mr. and Mrs. William, 312

Harry Hill's Dance Hall, 208

Harvey, Delilah, 79

Harvey, Officer, 153

Haslem, Robert, 307

Hastings, Catherine "Kate," 102 -5, 150 , 159 -64, 169 , 223

Hathaway, Caroline, 100 -101, 223

Havens, Henry, 230 -31

Hawhurst, Lydia Ann, 312

Hazard, Clara, 204 , 272 -73, 293 , 297 -98, 304 , 311 , 317 , 335

Henriques, Virginia, 56

Hentwish, Joe, 289

Hill, Jane, 56 , 314

Hill, Shannon E., xiv

Hoag, Alexander and Melinda, 121 -23, 291 , 368 n.34

Hobson, Barbara, 68 , 352 n.69, 354 n.99, 355 n.10

Hoffman, Catherine (Mrs. Shay Hoffman), 291 , 295 -96

Hoffman, Ogden, 151 , 376 n.69, 396 n.117

Hoffman's Bar, 295

Holland, John (alias Marquis), 165 , 249

Holly, Ellen, 170

Home for the Friendless, 39

Homosexuality and lesbianism, 306 -8

Hone, Philip, 18 , 178 , 182 , 191 , 200 , 254 , 282 , 374 n.38, 377 n.69, 398 n.78

Hook, the. See Brothel addresses/prostitution locations: Corlears Hook

"Hooker," 379 -80n.34

Hopson, Justice, 211

House of Refuge, 24 , 25 , 42 , 49 , 61 , 73 , 77 , 78 , 87 , 139 , 213 , 266 , 285 , 287 , 289 , 301 , 327 ;

mentioned, 40 , 41 , 43 , 44 , 45 , 46 , 88 , 205 , 234 , 280 , 281 , 310 , 312 , 313 , 315 , 316

Howard, Emma, 157

Howard, Fanny, 133

Howard, Mary, 185

Howard, Mrs., 275

Howell, Anna, 314

Hoyt, Christine and Caroline, 310

Hubbard, Mariah, 74 , 88

Huckstering, 209 , 251

Huson, Phebe, 77

Hyer, Thomas, 170

I

Illegitimacy, 59 , 312

Immigrants/immigration, 45 -46, 176 , 352 n.64, 354 n.99, 377 n.6;

laws related to, 134 ;

percentage of prostitutes foreign-born, 53 -54, 55 , 352 n.69;

public disdain for, 52 -53, 191 -92;

mentioned, 71 , 73 , 82 , 84 , 95 , 118 , 125 -26, 171 , 193 , 194 , 212 . See also


427

New York City population: immigrants and ethnic clusters

Incest, 77

Indentures, 41 -43, 64 , 74 , 213 , 289 , 301

Infants:

abandonment of, 242 , 316 , 389 n.78;

and infanticide, 241 -42, 316 ;

mortality rates, 242

Infertility, 242

Ingersoll, Caroline, 105 , 151 -52, 165 , 182 , 225

Inquests, 159 , 165 , 233 , 242 , 331 , 395 n.92

Intelligence offices, 72 -73

Interfacial sex. See Prostitution: black and interfacial

Irish immigrants, 53 -54, 84 , 352 n.64

J

Jackson, Dr. Charles, 237 -38

Jackson, Jane Ann, 168 , 185

Jackson, Mrs., 291

Jeffreys, Elizabeth, 167

Jewell, Mary, 166

Jewett, Helen, 9 -16, 10, 14 , 184 , 276 , 277 , 322 , 325 , 339 n.11, 391 nn.22-23;

clients of, 254 -66, 334 -36;

correspondence of, 15 -16, 25 -26, 203 -4, 214 , 256 -66, 271 -80, 293 , 297 -302, 304 , 311 , 318 -19, 322 , 331 -36;

earnings of, 13 , 88 , 339 n.10;

murder and trial, 9 -16, 34 , 35 , 63 , 150 , 172 , 234 , 254 , 274 , 280 , 375 n.55

J.J.A.S. (Jewett's client), 335

Jocelin, Dr. Benjamin A., 275

"John," 390 n.3. See also Prostitutes' relationships with men: as clients

John Allen's Dance Hall, 208

Judson, Edward Zane Carroll (Ned Buntline), 131 , 161 -65, 169 , 218 , 373 n.12

Jumel, Eliza Bowen (Mrs. Stephen Jumel, Mrs. Aaron Burr, alias Eliza Brown), 282 -84, 283

Jumel, Stephen, 282

Juvenile justice, 139

K

Kane, Jane, 399 n.57

Kanth (Kranth), Louisa and Charles, 291

Kelly, Mary, 295

Kelly, Miss, 185

Kelly, Rhoda, 314

Kemp, Mary, 234

Ketchum, Justice, 153

Kidd, Keziah Anne, 287 , 301

Kinmon, John, 226

Kissner, Captain, 109

L

Ladies Home Mission Society, 192

"Lallah Rook," 261

Landlords, of prostitution, 133 -34. See also Delaplaine, John F.; Livingston, John R.

Lane, Catherine, 45

Langdon, Mrs., 301

Laraty, Mr. (Jewett's client), 13

Laudanum, 248

Lavoie, Felicite (alias Catherine Stone), 286

Law enforcers. See Police/law enforcers Laws. See Abortion' laws against; Adultery, and laws against; Disorderly house/ persons: law; Immigrants/immigration: laws related to; Landlords, of prostitution; Seduction laws; Tenement house laws; Vagrancy law

Lawson, M., 274

LeCompt (LeCount), Miss, 302

Lee, Colonel, 43

Legal system, male dominance of, 2 , 113 , 139 -40

Legislature, New York, 138 , 141 -42, 281

Lenox, James, 178

LeRoy, Bob, 282

LeRoy, Jake, 201 , 282 , 387 n.58, 395 n.92

Lesbianism, 306 -8

Leslie, Ann, 105

Leve, Jane, 312

Lewis, Elizabeth, 105 , 310

Lewis, Maria (Maggie), 310

Lewis, Mary, 180

Licensing of prostitutes. See Prostitution: licensing and regulation of; St. Louis, regulation of prostitution in

Livingston, John R., 129 , 292

Lloyd, Ann, 241

Lockwood, Charles, 178 , 180

Logue, Eliza, 170

Lord, Jane (Mrs. Jacob Lord), 314

Low, Cornelius, 178

Lowndes, Justice, 211

Ludlow, Eliza, 168

Lynch, Judge, 121


428

Lyon, Margaret and Sarah, 310

Lyon, Mrs., 185

M

McCabe, James D., Jr., 192 , 198 -99, 219 , 228 , 245 -46

McCord, Jane, 105 , 183

McCready, Irene, 165

McDermott, Margaret, 125 -26

McDowall, Rev. John, 9 , 17 -21;

1831 report by, 18 , 24 , 27 , 65 , 118 -19, 176 , 268 ;

estimates of prostitutes, 18 , 27 , 30 ;

method of calculating numbers of prostitutes, 343 n.39;

mentioned, 27 , 30 , 60 , 65 , 93 , 118 , 176 , 238 , 243 , 268 , 317 , 340 n.21

McDowall's Journal , 20 , 268 , 317 , 341 n.21

McNeal, Elizabeth, 73

Magdalen Asylum, 234

Magdalen Facts , 19

Magdalen Society of 1812, 27

Malloy, J. Ann, 183 , 309 -10, 317

Malloy, Mary., 309 -10, 317

Mangren (Mangin), Bridget, 49 , 78 , 350 n.51

Mansfield, Mary, 270

Maria, 169

Marshall, Cinderella, 170 , 185 , 223 -24, 249 -50, 396 n. 114

Marston, George P. See Easy, Bill

Martin, Arabella, 242

Matsell, Police Chief George, 29 , 30 , 51 , 213

May, Delia, 271

May Day, 28 , 182 -83

Meade, Abby (alias Abby Meyer), 43 , 105 , 164 , 166 , 185 , 348 n.35

Meadows, Julia, 171

Mechanics, 193 , 280 , 287

Men: authoritarian role of, see Patriarch-alism; and Victorian view of sexual nature, 66 , 69 , 70

Meyer (Myer), Abby. See Meade, Abby

Meyers, Captain, 43

Michigan Medical Center, University of: fertility study, 242

Miller, Adeline (alias Adelia Furman), 37 -40, 46 , 105 , 153 , 155 , 163 , 168 , 183 , 284 , 292 , 317 , 347 nn.20-21, 365 n.98, 385 n.18

Miller, Anne, 185 , 211

Miller, Henry, 37

Miller, Mary, 310

Miller, Nelson, 38 , 153 , 317

Miller daughters, 38 , 153 , 317

Millinery workers and establishments, 26 , 42 , 73

Mills, Frances, 295

Misogyny, 167

Missionaries, 18 , 228 , 386 n.35

Mitchell, Maria, 295 , 317

Mobility of citizens, 181

Moore, Mary, 155

Moral Education Society of New York, 138

Moralism, nineteenth-century, 11 , 24 , 64 , 86 , 134 , 139 , 144 , 147 , 213 , 215 , 247 , 322 -23

Moral reform/reformers, 154 , 228 ;

attitudes on prostitution, 11 , 65 -67, 86 -87, 90 , 140 , 355 n.10;

movement, 9 , 17 -21, 22 ;

societies, 18 , 20 , 66 , 311

Morphine, 246

Morris, Robert, 120 , 331 , 334 , 367 n.22

Mortality See Children: mortality rates; Prostitutes: mortality and suicide of

Mott, Lucretia, 138

Myers, Dorothy, 185

N

Nathan, Benjamin, 165

National Police Gazette , 333 -35

National Theatre, 165 , 194

Near, Rachel, 88

Ned Buntline's Own , 161

Neighborhoods, New York City. See New York City population

Newspaper editors, controversies of, 161 -62, 374 n.38

New York City population, 52 ;

demographic and geographic patterns, 175 -95, 378 nn.20-21;

immigrants and ethnic clusters, 52 -54, 118 -19, 176 -77

New York City residents. See Black New York residents; Foreign-born residents; "Respectable" residents

New York Daily Times , and Mayor Wood's reform program, 112 -15

New York Female Benevolent Society, 20

New York Female Moral Reform Society, 66 , 311

New York Herald , 9 -11


429

New York legislature, 138 , 141 -42, 281

New York Magdalen Society, 18 , 43 , 89 , 268 . See also McDowall, Rev. John: 1831 report by

New York Public Library, 178

New York Society for the Prevention of Paupers, 65

New York Society Library, 178

Niles, George, 230

Norman, Amelia (alias Lydia Brown), 141 -43, 170

Nosworthy, William, 171

O

O'Grady, Mary, 78

O'Kille, Francis (also Frances, Fanny), 105 , 185 , 290

Old Brewery (Five Points tenement), 189

Olympic Theatre, 200

Opium, 244 , 245

Orphans: as prostitutes, 72 , 76 , 357 nn.34-35;

as wards of prostitutes, 295 , 317

Osborne, Justice B. W., 109 -10

Ostrander, John, 156

Overseers of the Poor, 133

P

"Palace of mirrors," 157 , 220

Panel houses, 199 , 351 n.63;

panel thieves, 122 , 199 , 230 , 267 , 291

Parent-Duchatelet, A. J. B., 22 , 60 , 137 , 218 , 349 n.42

Paris, Catherine (alias Elizabeth Salters), 63 -64, 99 , 331 -32

Parker, Amanda, 223

Park Theatre, 134 , 171 , 200 -204, 266 , 294 -95, 382 n.68, 383 n.88, 391 n.22

Parlor houses. See Brothels

Paternalism, 113

Patriarchalism, 2 , 113 , 143 , 144 , 321 -23

Penitentiary hospital, 233

Penny, Virginia (How Women Can Make Money ), 81 -82

Penny press. See Popular press

Perkins, Ann, 129

Personal property, 36 -37, 39 , 44 , 63 -64, 95 , 102 -5

Pessen, Edward, 99 -100;

method of calculating property in current dollars, 346 n.10

Philadelphia. See Prostitutes: Philadelphia connections of

Phillips, Matilda, 295

Phillips, Mrs., 241

Phillips, Nancy, 310

Pierce, Maria, 35

Pimps/pimp system, 4 , 94 , 267 -68;

development of system, 392 n.41;

use of term, 362 n.84

Pine Knot Bitters, 233

Place, Emma (alias Emma Allen), 157

Police/law enforcers, 28 , 109 , 114 , 124 , 132 , 145 -58;

abuse of prostitutes by, 155 -56;

corruption of, 147 -50, 157 , 292 , 372 n.10;

fee system of, 146 -51;

personalized/discretionary law enforcement by, 146 , 149 , 154 -55, 173 ;

records of, 26 , 27 ;

reform of, 148 , 152 , 372 n.7;

and reports and records mentioned, 26 , 27 , 29 , 31 , 119 , 127 , 133 ;

in variety of official roles, 146 -48, 154 ;

working with prostitutes, 150 -52, 156 -57, 231 , 292 . See also Disorderly house/persons: law; Matsell, Police Chief George; Vagrancy law

Popular literature of prostitution, 21 , 68 , 218 -19

Popular press (penny press), 21 , 27 -29, 119 , 121 , 141 , 142 , 160 -61, 237 ;

descriptions of prostitutes in, 13 , 35 , 162 , 288

Population changes. See New York City population: demographic and geographic patterns

Pornographic literature, 39 , 95 , 292

Porter, Rachel, 105 , 166

Potter, Julia, 247

Poverty: areas of, 177 , 186 -88, 191 -92;

as related to prostitution or vice, 46 , 51 -52, 65 , 117 , 119 , 126 , 178 , 182 , 212

Powell, Mrs., 295

Pratt, Elizabeth (Eliza), 105 , 163 , 239

Price, Mrs., 185

Prime, Rev. Samuel, 60 , 150 , 155 , 305

Prison, 18 , 116 , 118 , 126 -27, 142 , 156 , 165 , 247

Progressives, 5 , 340 n.17

Property assessments. See Tax: assessments

Property owners, female, 96 , 98 -99

Prostitutes: ages of, 33 , 48 -49, 50 , 62 ;

and alcohol and drugs, 80 , 243 -47;

as assertive citizens, 145 -49, 157 -72,


430

Prostitutes (continued )

173 , 174 , 224 , 315 ;

black, 45 , 55 -58, 62 , 169 , 295 , 314 , 317 , 352 n.70, 353 n.72;

character and credibility of, 11 , 35 , 65 , 131 , 172 -73, 217 ;

child, 24 , 49 -51, 205 , 209 , 212 -13, 234 , 350 nn.49, 58;

collective profile of, 47 -62, 349 nn.42, 44;

community attitudes toward, 3 , 11 , 112 -16, 139 , 322 -23;

in court hearings, 118 , 151 , 158 , 159 , 165 ;

economic situation of, 13 , 17 , 62 , 87 -92, 96 , 99 -106, 219 , 339 n.10;

emotional/psychological well-being of, 247 , 248 -50, 316 , 318 ;

exploitation of, 94 , 293 , 299 -300;

family background and relationships of, 60 , 75 -77, 90 , 213 , 308 -17;

foreign-born, 33 , 52 -55, 60 , 61 , 62 , 193 , 194 , 206 , 212 , 291 , 352 nn.64, 69, 354 n.99;

harassment of, 56 , 112 , 131 , 155 , 171 ;

legal status and treatment of, 2 , 3 , 112 -16, 369 n.66;

length of time in profession, 3 , 40 , 46 , 48 , 59 , 60 -61, 62 , 88 , 91 -93, 99 -100, 183 , 184 ;

lifestyle of, 62 , 77 , 89 -90, 243 -48, 298 , 302 -3, 323 , 398 n.30;

marriage and divorce of, 58 , 282 -91, 396 n.117;

medical examinations of, 111 , 137 -38, 232 , 370 n.84, 387 n.50;

mobility of, economic and social, 2 , 60 -61, 91 ;

mobility of, geographic, 181 -84, 379 nn.27,28;

mortality and suicide of, 61 , 248 , 316 , 318 ;

motherhood and pregnancy of (see also Contraception), 37 -38, 58 -59, 78 , 154 , 178 , 234 -37, 241 -42, 282 , 295 , 310 -18, 389 n.77;

name choice of, 249 -50;

numbers of, 18 , 26 -33, 345 nn.49,51;

occupational backgrounds of, 59 -60, 340 n.16;

personal profiles of, 9 -16, 34 -46;

Philadelphia connections of, 37 , 272 -73, 279 , 287 , 297 -300, 304 , 391 n.23;

soliciting customers, 203 , 208 , 209 -15, 302 ;

tolerance of, by community, 155 , 180 , 205 ;

as victims and victimizers, 11 , 21 , 65 -68, 74 -75, 80 , 133 , 140 , 218 , 322 -23;

as working women, 1 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 33 , 323 -24. See also Brothelkeepers; Brothels; Disorderly house/persons: law; Police/law enforcers; Prostitutes' relationships with men/women; Prostitution, causes of; Rape; Streetwalkers; Tax assessments; Vagrancy law; Venereal disease; and names of individual prostitutes

Prostitutes' relationships with men, 253 -92;

in business, 290 -92;

as clients, 57 , 139 , 218 , 219 -20, 226 -27, 249 , 253 -57, 292 , 299 , 386 n.28, 390 n.3;

as friends, 256 , 259 -67, 293 , 373 n.13;

and hostility, 255 -57, 391 n.7;

as lovers, 94 , 218 , 230 , 267 -82, 301 ;

in marriage, 52 , 281 -92;

as partners in crime, 114 , 230 -31, 351 n.63;

and violence, 151 , 160 , 171 , 173 , 202 , 229 -30, 240 , 241 , 255 , 257 , 270 -72, 280 , 305 , 314 -15, 375 n.55;

and violence by groups, 38 , 167 -69, 170 , 181 . See also Police/law enforcers; Rape

Prostitutes' relationships with women, 293 -319;

in contemporary stereotypes, 293 -94;

as friends, 78 -80, 100 -104, 293 -94, 296 -308, 315 , 318 -19;

in leisure activities, 298 , 302 -3;

as mothers and daughters, 36 , 78 , 178 , 282 , 310 -11;

in networking, 100 -103, 324 ;

as sisters and relatives, 78 , 308 -10;

and violence, 151 , 294 -96. See also Brothelkeepers

Prostitution:

black and interfacial, 55 -58, 191 -92, 194 , 254 -55, 353 nn.72,82;

dangers and disadvantages of, 3 , 23 , 90 , 211 , 227 -31, 232 -48;

definition of, 26 , 342 n.36;

economic or occupational opportunity of, 1 , 17 , 36 , 38 -40, 62 -63, 68 , 86 , 96 , 324 ;

European, 22 , 23 , 33 , 136 -37, 175 , 206 , 349 nn.42,44;

geographic distribution of, 31 , 95 -96, 97 , 175 -80, 186 -95, 362 n.87;

hierarchy of, 218 -22, 268 ;

licensing and regulation of, 21 , 23 -25, 132 , 135 -39;

moral reformers' responses to, 11 , 17 -21, 65 -68, 86 -87, 90 , 355 n.10;

primary and secondary institutions of, 196 -209;

public attitudes toward, 17 , 18 , 132 , 139 , 173 , 180 -81, 365 n.2;

studies of, 22 -25;

subculture, 248 -50, 306 , 318 ;

surveys and estimates of, 27 , 31 -33, 343 n.39, 344 n.43;

working


431

conditions of, 89 -90, 187 -88, 191 , 195 , 219 -22. See also Brothels; Laws; Police/law enforcers; Prostitutes; Streetwalkers; Third tier

Prostitution, causes of: double standard, 75 ;

economic rewards, 36 -40, 44 -45, 87 -106;

entrapment and trickery, 67 , 71 -74;

evil influences of literature, dress, and theater, 205 , 356 n. 17;

home and family life, 60 , 75 -80;

inclination and lifestyle choice, 77 , 80 -81;

influence of companions, 77 -80;

lack of alternatives, 17 , 67 , 82 -84, 87 , 319 ;

moral weakness, 65 ;

positive appeal, 68 , 81 ;

poverty/destitution, 66 , 81 -86;

Sanger survey, 72 ;

seduction and abandonment, 66 , 68 -71, 74 ;

twentieth-century analysis, 355 n.4, 358 nn.48, 50

Purity reform, 66 . See also Moral reform/reformers: movement

Purse, W., 271

R

Racism, 55 -57, 191 , 254 -55, 353 nn.72, 82, 398 n.45

Rape, 71 , 73 , 156 , 229 , 239 -40, 313 ;

cases pursued in court, 51 , 170 -71, 350 n. 58

Ray, Charles, 289

Ray, Mary Ann, 77

Real estate holdings, 105 . See also Landlords, of prostitution

Redding, Mrs., 223

"Red Drop," 233

Red light district, 95 , 137 , 268

Reed, Mrs. Francis, 286 , 315

Reffell, Mary, 271

Reformers:

evangelical/moral, 65 , 228 ;

Mayor Wood's reform program, 109 -14, 212 -13. See also Moral reform/reformers

"Respectable" residents, interacting with prostitutes, 18 , 29 , 35 , 133 , 134 , 191 , 194 , 202 , 203 , 210 , 378 n.13

Restelle, Madame (Ann Lohman), 23 , 141 , 237 -38, 240

"Restellism," 23

Rhinggold, Benjamin, 271

Rice, Elizabeth, 131

Rice, Hannah, 43

Richmond Hill Theatre, 200

Ridgeway, James, 292

Ridgley, Kate, 105 , 157 -58, 220 -21, 222 , 285 n. 18

Riots, in New York City, 147 -48

Roberts, Mary Jane, 313

Roberts, Nathan, 230

Robins, Mrs., 311

Robinson, Jane, 228

Robinson, Mary, 185

Robinson, Richard (alias Frank Rivers), 10 -11, 34 -35, 249 , 254 , 261 -64, 274 , 300 -301, 394 n.81;

correspondence of, 257 , 275 , 278 -80, 297 , 331 -35

Robinson, Solon (Hot Corn: Life Scenes in New York Illustrated ), 218

Rollough, George (alias Black Hawk), 231

Roper, Mr., 310

Rosen, Ruth, 4 -5, 33 , 349 n.44

Rosenzweig, Jacob, 237

Rowe, Harriet, 309 -10

Rowe, Kate, 180 , 309 -10

Rue, John, 270

Rural women. See Prostitution, causes of: entrapment and trickery; Women, nineteenth-century: as victims

Ryerson, Margaret, 151

S

Sage, Frances, 78 -79

Sailors, 187 -88, 193 , 255 , 314

St. Catherine's Church, 286

St. Louis, regulation of prostitution in, 139

Saloons, 147 , 187 -88, 196 , 206 -7

Salters, Elizabeth. See Paris, Catherine

Salvarsan, 232

Sands, Emma (Emma Sands v. People , 1838), 119 -21, 124

Sanger, Dr. William:

on abortion, 237 -38, 241 ;

on alcohol and drugs, 243 -44, 246 ;

on causes of prostitution, 69 , 71 , 72 , 73 , 76 , 78 -81;

description of study, 23 -25, 27 ;

on hierarchy and profile of prostitutes, 47 -49, 52 -53, 58 -62, 218 , 230 , 269 -70, 287 -88, 312 -13;

on legalization and regulation of prostitution, 137 -38;

on life expectancy of prostitutes, 60 -61;

on method of calculating number of prostitutes, 344 n.43, 345 n.51;

on number of prostitutes and houses, 29 -30, 31 , 32 ;

on profitability of prostitution, 88 -89, 96 ;

on


432

Sanger, Dr. William (continued )

relationships in community, 144 , 175 , 206 , 209 , 212 , 216 ;

on venereal disease, 227 , 232 -33

Sarles, Mrs. See Utter sisters

Saum, Lewis, 248

Savage, Lorenzo, 151

Scientific reformers and studies, 21 , 27 , 66 , 218

Scott, Susan, 185

Seamstresses, 26 , 42 , 59 , 82 -83, 85 -86, 141 , 305 -6, 340 n. 16

Seduction, 66 , 73 , 140 , 239 , 273

Seduction laws, 140 -43, 371 n.103

Seely, Catherine "Kitty" (Mrs. William Seely), 287 -88

Seigler, Phebe and Eliza, 310

"Separate spheres," 17 , 319

Sewally, Peter (alias Mary Jones, alias Eliza Smith), 307 -8

Sewing trades. See Seamstresses

Sex publications, 39 , 95 , 292

Sexual abuse, 113 ;

by employer, 73 -74, 86 , 313 ;

by police, 156

Sexual harassment, 155

Sexual nature of men and women, 66 , 69 , 70

Seymour, Mary, 316

Shannon, Susan, 169 , 173 , 185 , 291

Shott, Mrs., 185

Sickles, Daniel, 102 , 268 , 281 , 394 nn.88, 90

Simpson, Bishop Matthew, 30

Simpson, Edmund, 134 -35, 204 , 383 n.88

Sisterhood of women, 400 n. 5

Sloat, Dr. John, 241

Slums. See Five Points;

Tenements

Smith, Amanda, 315

Smith, Cecelia, 289

Smith, Dr. Charles, 23 , 29 , 47 -48, 50 , 60 , 136 , 200 , 217 , 218 , 232 , 247 , 269 -70;

on number of prostitutes, 343 n.41

Smith, Eliza, 129 , 140 , 185

Smith Harriet, 230 -31

Smith Isaac, 122 -23

Smith James (ahas "Mouse"), 231

Smith Jane, 166

Smith Julia Ann, 45

Smith Mary, 171

Smith Matthew Hale, 219

Smith, Susan, 238

Smith, Thomas, 284

"Social evil," 17 , 340 n. 17

Soule, Emma, 309 -10

Stafford, Lavinia, 185

Stansell, Christine, 5 , 285

Stanton, Elizabeth Cady, 138

Steen, Mary, 202 , 205

Stephens, Cyrenus, 291

Stephens, Moll, 169

Stevens, Ellen, 302

Stewart, Isabella, 166

Stewart, Mary, 170 , 273 -74

Stiles (Styles), Miss R., 185 , 302

Street, dangers of, 77 , 105 , 115 , 138 , 307

Street hucksters, 209 , 251

Streetwalkers/streetwalking:

areas of, 184 , 209 -10;

community response to, 209 , 211 , 212 -14;

dangers for, 211 , 244 ;

nativity of, 54 -55;

mentioned, 24 , 58 , 59 , 113 , 125 , 127 , 149 , 171 , 187 , 192 , 194 , 198 , 244 , 287 , 301 , 305 , 313

Striker, Susan, 74 -75, 289

Strong, George Templeton, 34 , 114 , 182 , 200 , 210 , 212 , 215 -16, 246 , 282 , 284 , 374 n.38, 377 n.69, 395 n.92

Suicide, 248 , 316 , 318

Suydam, Samuel A., 161

Sweet, Louis, 315 -16

Sweet, Sarah, 55 -56

Sweet, Susan "Jenny," 157 , 185 , 316

Swift, Ann, 180

T

Tait, William, 23 , 60 , 173

Tammany politics, 4 , 18 , 24 -25, 281 , 374 n.38

Tappan, Arthur, 18 -19

Tappan, Lewis, 18

Taverns, 196 , 206

Tax:

appeals, 163 -65;

assessments , 36 -37, 39 , 44 , 96 , 99 -100, 102 -3, 105 , 159 -60, 182 ;

records, 25 , 95 , 310 ;

value in current dollars, 346 n.10

Taylor, Eliza, 239 , 240

Taylor, John, 291

Taylor, Robert, 39 , 152 -53, 160 , 239

Temperance, 243 , 246 -47

Tenement house laws, 134

Tenements, 51 , 83 , 178 , 179 , 187 , 190 -92, 198

Theaters:

attempts to regulate, 134 -35;

as


433

secondary prostitution institution, 199 -206, 383 n.95;

violence in, 202 , 272 ;

mentioned, 302 , 383 n.90, 383 n.94. See also names of individual theaters ; Third tier

Theft, 275 , 307 . See also Brothels/prostitution boardinghouses: theft in

Third tier (in theaters), 134 -35, 199 -206, 201 , 271 , 294 , 301 , 382 n.70, 383 nn.90, 94, 95

Thomas, Ann, 163

Thompson, Agnes, J., 274

Thompson, Amelia, 166

Thompson, Ellen (Nelle), 105 , 223 , 314

Tombs, the (prison), 111 , 141 , 155

Tomlinson, Mr., 112

Townsend, Rosina (also Thompson, née Rebecca Rosana Brown), 34 -36, 129 , 150 -51, 220 -21;

aliases, 185 , 249 ;

assets, 36 , 105 ;

role as madam, 40 , 226 , 386 n.22;

testimony at Robinson trial, 172 , 225 , 274 , 331 ;

mentioned, 12 , 63 , 64 , 83 , 100 , 264 , 290 , 299 , 365 n.98

Tracy, Maria, 294

Treating, 36 -37, 225 -27

Tucker, Emily (alias Emily Tooker), 249

Turnbull, Captain, 109

Turner, Rosannah, 185

Tuttle, Sarah (madam), 102 -5, 159 -60, 163 , 185

Tuttle, Sarah (servant), 238

U

"Unfortunate's Friend," 233

Union Theological Seminary, 178

Urban changes, 146 -48, 192

Utter sisters, Ann Jeanette (Mrs. Sarles) and Mary Ann, 40 -42, 286 , 301 , 310 , 348 n.28

U.S. Hotel, Westpoint, 45

V

Vagrancy law, 113 -24, 144 , 159 , 365 n.2, 367 n. 20;

arrests, by ward, 120 ;

arrests, by year, 128 ;

challenges to, 119 -26;

defined, 117 -18;

as expedient tool, 118 -26;

as unconstitutional, 120 ;

vagueness of, 117

Vagrant/vagrancy, 114 -17, 119 -28, 211 , 212 , 233 ;

mentioned, 46 , 109 , 191 , 211 , 280 . See also Vagrancy law

Van Allen, Mrs., 312

Van Fost, Ellen and Robert, 314

Van Norden, Sarah, 42

Vanvorst, C. J., 314

Venereal disease, 23 -24, 136 -38, 227 , 232 -34, 289 , 387 nn.50, 55, 58;

by age, 234 ;

medical examinations for, 111 , 137 ;

medical treatment for, 232 -33;

mentioned, 21 , 43 , 111 , 241 , 242 , 280 , 287

Vice, 27 , 177 , 190 , 205 ;

equated with foreigners, poverty, and prostitution, 52 , 186 , 188 , 191 -92, 212

Vice Commission of Chicago, 340 n. 17

Victorian era: attitudes toward women, 5 , 51 , 66 , 133 , 322 . See Men: and Victorian view of sexual nature; Women, nineteenth-century: sexual nature of

Vidal, Gore (Burr ), 11

Violence. See Prostitutes' relationships with men/women: and violence; Rape

W

Wade, Henry, 111

Wade, Matilda, 109 -12, 114 , 120 -21, 125 -26, 171

Waiter girls, 207

Walker, Jane (alias James Walker, George Moore Wilson), 307 -8

Walkowitz, Judith, 4 , 218 , 241 , 349 n.44

Wall, Mary, 129 , 167 , 185

Wallack's Theatre, 204 , 383 n.86

Walling, George, 149 -50, 158

Walton, Grace, 309 -10

Wandering Willie, 261 , 265 -67, 332 , 335 , 401 n.5

Wards:

eighth, 53 , 54 , 95 , 96 , 109 -10, 114 , 176 -77, 186 , 193 , 194 ;

fifteenth, 194 ;

fifth, 53 , 54 , 95 , 96 , 114 , 150 , 176 -77, 186 , 194 ;

fourteenth, 109 , 110 , 193 ;

fourth, 187 ;

map of, 97 ;

personal property, female ownership by ward, 98 , 99 ;

seventeenth, 193 ;

seventh, 187 ;

sixth, 95 -96, 114 , 119 , 186 , 192 -93;

tenth, 193 ;

third, 113 , 186

Watchmen, 146 -47;

testimony of, 131 . See also Police/law enforcers

Waters, Jim, 171

Waters, John, 286

Water Street Home for Women, 285


434

Watson, Adeline, 280

Watson, Charles, 122 , 123

Wealthy citizens, 177 -78, 187 , 195

Webb, J. G., 374 n.38

Webb, James W. (editor of the Courier and Enquirer ), 161

Weber, Eliza, 50

Weldon, Ann, 185

West, Mrs. Phebe, 71 , 291 , 296

West (American), prostitution in the, 337 n.1, 349 n.44

Western, Jane Graham (alias Jane "Jenny"

Weston, Jenny Graham), 105 , 168 , 249 , 294

Western, Madame (Philadelphia), 274

Weston, Jane. See Western, Jane Graham

Weston, Judge Nathan, 12

Weyman, Rebecca, 100 -101, 105 , 314

White, Fanny, 102 -5, 153 , 163 , 165 , 201 , 268 , 281 -82, 284 , 395 n.92

Wife abuse. See Abuse

Wilkes, George (editor of the Police Gazette ), 161

Williams, Elizabeth, 229

Williams, Ellen, 230

Williams, Jane, 169 , 171 , 185

Williams, Maria, 301

Williams, Sarah, 88

Williamson, Phoebe, 321 -22, 325

Willis, Charlotte, 78 , 311

Willis, Rebecca, 105

Wilson, Ann, 295

Wilson, Catherine, 145

Wilson, Jane, 185

Wilson, Louisa, 200

Wilson, Lydia, 294

Winslow, Jane (Jenny), 185 , 223 , 302 , 309

Womanhood:

"cult of true womanhood," 17 , 67

Women, nineteenth-century:

in control of prostitution, 94 ;

economic situation of, 67 ;

legal position of, 95 , 112 ;

nature of, 217 , 322 ;

occupations of, 81 -85;

as poor, 112 , 113 -14, 126 ;

rights movement, 17 , 138 , 323 ;

sexual nature of, 66 , 69 , 70 ;

"sphere" of, 17 , 112 -13, 318 ;

as victims, 67 -68;

working-class, occupations and wages of, 81 -86

Wood, Mayor Fernando, 52 , 109 , 112 , 114 , 125 , 138 , 212 , 213 , 351 n.63, 365 n.2

Woods, Kate (Hotel de Wood), 220 -21

Working class, 193 , 219 ;

views of prostitution, 285 , 312 . See also Women, nineteenth-century: working-class

World Whores Conference, 400 n.5

Wyman, Justice, 57 , 173 , 233


 

Preferred Citation: Hill, Marilynn Wood. Their Sisters' Keepers: Prostitution in New York City, 1830-1870. Berkeley:  University of California Press,  1993. http://ark.cdlib.org/ark:/13030/ft8199p209/